The cover by V. E. Pyles doesn't illustrate any of the stories in the January 1, 1938 issue. Pyles isn't exactly taking advantage of a recent change in Argosy's cover design that eliminated the red band across the top third that had been virtually the magazine's trademark. The redesign gave cover artists more room to work with and the results were sometimes impressive, but I've come around to preferring the old red-band style, if only because that's what's on the covers in the years I consider Argosy's best, just a couple of years before this issue appeared. The feature story this week is Richard Sale's "A Swap for Stonewall Jackson," which is, as you may have guessed, a Civil War story. Sale is best known in pulps for his detective stories. He graduated to screenwriting and directing (as did fellow pulpsters Alan LeMay and Charles Marquis Warren, the latter of whom may be getting more attention lately than in a long time). I haven't read this particular story (but you can!) but I've read some other Civil War stuff of his and it's not his best stuff. The other star writers this issue are Karl Detzer, who specialized in firefighter stories but here continues his World's Fair Mystery serial, and Richard Wormser, whose "Isle of Yellow Girls" was the latest in his series about Dave McNally, a kind of younger, tougher Carl Denham (he compares himself with Frank Buck, but which name do you recognize?) who travels the world searching for exotic attractions to sell to circuses, zoos, theaters, etc. I'll let him introduce himself:
"I've fought," McNally said, "in every latitude and longitude on this Earth.From Hey Rubes in Iowa to bandits on the Caucasus, from cannibals in Borneo to headhunters in Africa. I've been in eight revolutions, three wars, five race riots and so many fights I've scar tissue from the Achilles tendon on my right heel to the mastoid bone on my left ear. I--"
After which McNally faints from a fever. He may have been a little delirious, but it sounds like an interesting career. "Isle" is a good story that keeps you guessing about what sort of trouble McNally has gotten himself into as the trouble escalates to apparent murder. Wormser disrupts expectations early by introducing a character as a "Kanaka," which was the standard term for South Sea island people who are usually portrayed in pulp as simple savages. This story's Kanaka, however, is a high-school educated Hawaiian (and an Eagle Scout) who often seems to know more than McNally, especially about what's really going on in the story. That actually makes him a suspicious character, especially when he seems to be consorting with some Japanese, but I'll let those who are interested figure things out themselves by reading the story. You'll note that the interior artist is teasing readers just a bit by having one of the yellow girls barely show some nipple on the opening page. That bit of exploitation aside, "Yellow Girls" refreshingly avoids the most blatant stereotypes of pulp fiction without succumbing to the temptation to make everyone generically alike. McNally is an entertaining character whose adventures have amused me in the past. I have some more McNally stories in my personal Argosy collection that I hope to share with you down the line. For now, the entire January 1, 1938 issue is available as part of the pulp trove at unz.org, where you can download individual stories for your reading convenience. This issue also has one of C. F. Kearns's stories about his Northwest hero Handsled Burke, which are usually good stuff, a serial chapter by one of my favorite pulpsters, Eustace L. Adams, and the conclusion of a serial by Lester (Doc Savage) Dent that isn't (based on my reading of an earlier chapter) one of the great man's finest hours. Taken as a whole, this is a modest sample of what Argosy has to offer, and there is more and better to come.
I've been a pulp collector for over 50 years so I'll be interested in your future articles about the magazines. I noticed you mention the "big four" general interest pulps, all of which I collect. In addition to ADVENTURE, ARGOSY, SHORT STORIES, and BLUE BOOK, I would add two additional titles that were very influential:ReplyDelete
ALL STORY(1905-1920) has been called perhaps the most influential pulp of them all because it emphasized early SF, basically starting with the work of Edgar Rice Burroughs in 1912. There were 444 issues before it was absorbed by ARGOSY in 1920. I recently completed my set of ALL STORY, a project that took decades.
THE POPULAR MAGAZINE(1903-1931) was called the training ground for the slicks and lasted over 600 issues. I completed my file of this title a couple years ago. It was the subject of major two part article in BLOOD n THUNDER magazine, issues 24 and 25.
I would therefore say there was a "big six" in the general fiction magazine category. There were other general titles of course but none of them on the level of the big six. For instance TOP NOTCH, COMPLETE STORIES, and PEOPLES all lasted for several years.
Welcome to the blog, Walker. You're a familiar name on the other pulp blogs I read and I hope you'll like this one. I don't know who coined the "big four" concept, but I'd guess the idea was based on the pulp environment of the mid-late Thirties instead of the longer view you recommend. My own pulp reading doesn't extend back to All Story's heyday and I haven't yet seen an issue of The Popular but judging by influence they definitely were major pulp players.ReplyDelete